
Guest blog from Allison Gannon, Head of Revenue Operations at BWF
Allison Gannon, BWF’s Head of Revenue Operations, is inspired by the fact that billions of dollars are raised annually in the U.S. because people rally around an important mission to create action and change. Using her 8+ years of experience, Allison engages with current and prospective clients to identify the best solution to achieve their goals, empowers the BWF team to ensure they are successful in all their endeavors, and coordinates with industry partners to develop the best services for our clients and the sector. With innovative vision and passion, Allison leads a team focused on client experience, marketing, business development, and strategic partnerships.
The charity landscape is continuously evolving, requiring organisations to create innovative strategies to achieve their goals and fulfill their missions. Relying solely on guesswork or traditional spreadsheets to interpret your donor landscape can lead you to miss opportunities and hidden potential within your database.
Predictive analytics, also known as predictive AI, uses historical constituent data, statistical algorithms, and machine learning to analyse past trends and anticipate future fundraising outcomes. This article explores four ways to merge data science with prospect research to identify and upgrade potential major donors.
1. Conduct prospect development and research
Before switching to an entirely technology-based prospect research process, it’s important to understand the foundational metrics that inform intelligent predictive models. Bloomerang’s major gift fundraising guide defines strong major gift prospects as individuals with high wealth capacity, a philanthropic mindset, and an existing affinity for your cause. Taken together, these three indicators can help you identify individuals with the willingness and propensity to give to charities, and who also hold a strong connection to your organisation.
Here are some strategies to conduct effective prospect research:
- Look beyond visible assets: Analyse diverse wealth indicators, such as real estate holdings, recent retirements or business investments, and stock portfolios, to measure a prospect’s actual potential to give.
- Track charitable behaviour: Evaluate whether a prospect has a documented history of supporting causes similar to yours, either through board affinity, financial gifts, or volunteering, to gauge their overarching philanthropic mindset.
- Monitor direct charity affinity: Note previous engagements with your specific organisation. Frequent event attendance, a history of donations, and engagement with your newsletters and programming over a long period of time all indicate a strong dedication to your mission.
In addition to these traditional prospect research indicators, use psychographics to assess the motivations behind your donors’ giving. Qualitative feedback collected through targeted surveys, conversations with your donors, and testimonials can help you understand what draws people to your organisation in the first place. Use this information to create fundraising initiatives that reflect the values your charity and your audience share and encourage engagement.
2. Assess past fundraising
After conducting thorough prospect research, use your findings to identify individuals with the capacity to contribute major gifts. Incorporate AI predictive analytics to assess past giving capacity and behavioral patterns to determine when prospects may be primed to make a donation and optimize your ask strategy.
Here are some ways predictive analytics can help you develop a strategy to solicit major gifts:
- Evaluate previous gift amounts: If a donor has a history of contributing to your organization, you can estimate their anticipated future gift amounts and overall capacity to give based on their past giving patterns.
- Determine gift timelines: Some donors abide by a schedule of giving: they give monthly, quarterly, or even once a year. Use AI to identify these patterns, and send a gentle reminder to give or an impact report on the positive change their past giving had on your community just before their usual donation period.
- Track gift upgrades: Often, donors undergo a journey from one-time donors to regular contributors to major gift benefactors. A history of increasing gift amounts or regular donations may indicate an individual interested in contributing a large gift to your organization.
Predictive analytics can help your development team better understand the cadences and patterns of your supporters’ contributions. For example, you can use past donation data to identify periods when your organization receives significant capital, such as during the holidays or in a major campaign season. Combine this data with your prospect research to craft targeted asks for major gift prospects during high-donation periods.
3. Monitor engagement metrics
One of the strongest indicators of a willingness to give is engagement with your organization. Giving to past initiatives, previous event attendance and volunteer work, and interaction with outreach can help you identify and upgrade major donors.
Here are some ways predictive analytics can help you identify high-engagement individuals:
- Track open rates and click-through rates: Your outreach helps keep donors engaged with your organization. However, it can also indicate which programs and causes they are most invested in. Track which newsletters, communication types, and event advertisements your donors actively engage with to identify their strongest passions.
- Monitor event attendance: An increase in event attendance, volunteer work, and communication may indicate a willingness to contribute financially to your organization. AI can track each donor’s average attendance patterns and notify your team if they begin participating more frequently, as well as the initiatives they engage with.
- Flag long-term volunteers: Large-scale contributions don’t always show up as major gifts. Use AI to flag long-time supporters and volunteers. Then, send educational flyers that inform them about ways to stretch their contributions through matching gifts, community fundraising, and volunteer grant programs.
Your donors’ behavior and engagement with your organization clearly demonstrate their care for your cause, if your team knows where to look. Predictive analytics can help your team identify highly involved individuals who might be interested in contributing to your organization. AI solutions can also track which fundraising programs and initiatives your prospects show interest in, helping your team create a strategy to approach their major gift asks based on your supporters’ demonstrated interests and previous involvement.
4. Create highly targeted campaigns
Predictive analytics can help your team create highly targeted campaigns based on your prospect’s past giving and demonstrated interests, increasing your major gift conversion rate. The right messaging and clear communication of their gifts’ anticipated positive impact can make hesitant donors confident in their decision to give to your organization.
Predictive analytics don’t only apply to your fundraising initiatives. You can also use them to create effective marketing campaigns through these strategies:
- Identify primary communication channels: Use past open and response rates to determine whether your donors respond better to text, email, or direct mail outreach. Prioritize these channels when creating major gift campaigns and impact reports.
- Use past giving and engagement data: Historic engagement data can help your team tailor your solicitation communications towards initiatives that prospective donors are already invested in, framing your major gift ask as a contribution to a direct cause, program, or initiative they already have a stake in.
- Time your ask: The last thing you want to do is solicit a major gift immediately after a contributor has donated. Use AI to monitor your donors’ giving patterns, and time your major gift solicitation cadence to align with when you anticipate their next gift. This keeps your donor relationship from feeling transactional while encouraging deeper involvement.
BWF Zuri’s AI fundraising guide recommends pairing predictive analytics with generative AI to create personalized outreach messages. Include references to past engagement, initiative participation, and giving amounts in your major gift outreach to show prospective major gift donors that your team sees and appreciates their investment in your cause. Additionally, feature branded data representations and infographics showing the real-time impact of both the prospect’s previous contributions and the anticipated future impact of their major gift, so they can visualize how their contributions will create positive change.
Predictive analytics lets you get to know your donors on a personal level, helping your team increase your major gift conversion rate through highly personalized outreach. However, you should also prioritize building personal relationships with your major gift donors through phone calls, lunches, and other human-based outreach, in addition to digital campaigns. A close connection to your development team helps your major gift donors stay engaged with your organization and encourages repeat giving.
This post was written by a guest contributor. The views expressed are the author’s own and don’t necessarily reflect the positions of Fundraising Everywhere. Content from guest authors may reflect different approaches, experiences, or perspectives to those covered in other events and training.